Best Buy · 2024

Best Buy 2024

The best cigars at the best price.

Text: Editors

The best cigars at the best price. This is what many cigar lovers are looking for. We combed through our blind tastings of the year 2024 again to find out which cigars have received particularly good reviews AND are offered for a much lower price compared to others of the same rating. We mark those cigars in our magazine with the stamp BEST BUY. The basis for our decision is the price per gram of tobacco. 67 cigars have made it to this list and you should definitely give them a try.

Rated by the Cigar Journal tasting panel, blind, on the 100-point scale.

Best Buy 94 Points

Plasencia Cosecha 151 La Tradición Toro Honduras 149 x 21,4 | 5.875 x 54

Best Buy 93 Points

* Rojas Street Tacos Barbacoa Robusto Nicaragua 127 x 19,8 | 5 x 50
Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Box-Pressed Super Toro Sun Grown Nicaragua 152 x 23,8 | 6 x 60
A.J. Fernandez Enclave Habano Salomon Nicaragua 165 x 20,6 | 6.5 x 52

Best Buy 92 Points

VegaFina Classic Supremo EL 2024 Dom. Rep. 137 x 22,2 | 5.375 x 56
United Cigars Maduro Toro Dom. Rep. 152 x 21,4 | 6 x 54
Rocky Patel The Edge 20th Anniversary Toro Honduras 152 x 23,8 | 6 x 60
Rocky Patel LB1 Robusto Honduras 140 x 19,8 | 5.5 x 50
Rocky Patel Dark Star Robusto Honduras 140 x 19,8 | 5.5 x 50
Perdomo 20th Anniversary Sun Grown Churchill Nicaragua 178 x 22,2 | 7 x 56
Kinship 3 Tabaqueros Robusto Dom. Rep. 127 x 19,8 | 5 x 50
* Henry Clay War Hawk Toro Honduras 152 x 19,8 | 6 x 50
Flor de Copán Classic Corona Honduras 159 x 19,0 | 6.25 x 48
* 1502 Ruby Lancero Nicaragua 178 x 15,9 | 7 x 40

Best Buy 91 Points

VegaFina Prominente Dom. Rep. 191 x 19,8 | 7.5 x 50
VegaFina Classic Blas de Lezo Exclusivo España Dom. Rep. 133 x 19,0 | 5.25 x 48
San Lotano The Bull Torpedo Nicaragua 165 x 21,4 | 6.5 x 54
Perdomo Habano Bourbon Barrel Aged (BBA) Connecticut Churchill Nicaragua 178 x 21,4 | 7 x 54
Perdomo Double Aged 12 Years Vintage Gordo Extra Maduro Nicaragua 165 x 23,8 | 6.5 x 60
Perdomo 20th Anniversary Gordo Maduro Nicaragua 152 x 23,8 | 6 x 60
Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Champagne Connecticut Robusto Nicaragua 127 x 21,4 | 5 x 54
Nicaroma 6×54 Nicaragua 152 x 21,4 | 6 x 54
Leonel No. 511 Robusto Nicaragua 127 x 20,6 | 5 x 52
* Henry Clay War Hawk Corona Honduras 127 x 17,5 | 5 x 44
Corrida HON., Short Robusto+ Nicaragua 102 x 23,8 | 4 x 60
* Aliados Original Blend Churchill Honduras 178 x 19,8 | 7 x 50
Alec Bradley Magic Toast Toro Honduras 152 x 20,6 | 6 x 52
A.J. Fernandez Last Call Habano Flaquitas Nicaragua 152 x 18,3 | 6 x 46

Best Buy 90 Points

West Tampa Tobacco Company Red Toro Nicaragua 152 x 20,6 | 6 x 52
West Tampa Tobacco Company Black Toro Nicaragua 152 x 20,6 | 6 x 52
Villiger 1888 Torpedo Dom. Rep. 152 x 20,6 | 6 x 52
Villiger 1888 Nicaragua Churchill Nicaragua 178 x 18,6 | 7 x 47
VegaFina Classic Corona Dom. Rep. 146 x 17,1 | 5.75 x 43
Santa Damiana Classic Robusto Dom. Rep. 127 x 19,8 | 5 x 50
Santa Damiana Classic Churchill Dom. Rep. 178 x 19,0 | 7 x 48
* Rocky Patel Vintage 1992 Robusto Honduras 140 x 19,8 | 5.5 x 50
* Oscar Valladares The Oscar Connecticut Sixty Honduras 152 x 23,8 | 6 x 60
* Matilde Serena Robusto Dom. Rep. 133 x 19,8 | 5.25 x 50
Mata Hari Courtisane Robusto Other 124 x 19,8 | 4.875 x 50
La Aurora 107 Ecuador Robusto Dom. Rep. 127 x 19,8 | 5 x 50
Kristoff Tres Compadres 6×60 Dom. Rep. 152 x 23,8 | 6 x 60
Kristoff Shade Grown Churchill Dom. Rep. 178 x 19,8 | 7 x 50
J.C. Newman El Baton Robusto Nicaragua 127 x 21,4 | 5 x 54
J.C. Newman Brick House Bricktoberfest 2023 Nicaragua 152 x 20,6 | 6 x 52
Hemmys Maduro Piramides Dom. Rep. 152 x 20,6 | 6 x 52
Drew Estate Blackened Cigars S84 Shade to Black Toro Nicaragua 152 x 20,6 | 6 x 52
Diesel Vintage Series Robusto Gordo Nicaragua 127 x 22,2 | 5 x 56
Asylum Nyctophilia 54×6 Honduras 152 x 21,4 | 6 x 54
Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill Honduras 178 x 19,0 | 7 x 48
Alec Bradley Double Broadleaf Chunk Honduras 102 x 23,8 | 4 x 60

Best Buy 89 Points

United Cigars Natural Toro Dom. Rep. 152 x 21,4 | 6 x 54
* SP1014 Black The New Old World 6×54 Dom. Rep. 152 x 21,4 | 6 x 54
* Rocky Patel Vintage 1990 Robusto Honduras 140 x 19,8 | 5.5 x 50
Perla del Mar Corojo Double Toro Nicaragua 152 x 23,8 | 6 x 60
* Leaf by Oscar 10th Anniversary Criollo Sixty Honduras 152 x 23,8 | 6 x 60
K by Karen Berger Tailgate Toro Nicaragua 152 x 20,6 | 6 x 52
Kristoff Nicaragua Toro Dom. Rep. 159 x 21,4 | 6.25 x 54
Henry Clay War Hawk Robusto Honduras 127 x 21,4 | 5 x 54
* Flor de Copán Classic Titán Honduras 152 x 23,8 | 6 x 60
Firecracker by United Cigars Black Bomb Dom. Rep. 89 x 19,8 | 3.5 x 50
Dos Jotas Diarios 2020 Petit Corona Dom. Rep. 127 x 14,3 | 5 x 36
Alec Bradley MAXX The Fixx Honduras 127 x 23,0 | 5 x 58
Alec Bradley Connecticut Torpedo Honduras 156 x 20,6 | 6.125 x 52
Alec Bradley Double Broadleaf Gordo Honduras 152 x 23,8 | 6 x 60
Alec Bradley Black Market Esteli Toro Nicaragua 152 x 20,6 | 6 x 52
* 2012 by Oscar Sumatra Sixty Honduras 152 x 23,8 | 6 x 60

Best Buy – April 20, 2026

Looking Back: Cigar Journal’s Best Buy Cigars of 2018

Stay up to date and receive the latest cigar news, exclusive updates and special offers straight to your inbox.

We use your E-mail address for sending and usage analysis. Privacy policy.

Done, and thank you.

Please check your inbox and click the confirmation link to complete your subscription. If you do not see the message, please check your spam or junk folder. We are delighted to have you as part of our community.

Your Cigar Journal Team

Best Buy 2024

Best Buy 94 Points

Best Buy 93 Points

Best Buy 92 Points

Best Buy 91 Points

Best Buy 90 Points

Best Buy 89 Points

Related Articles

Cigar Journal’s Best Buy Cigars Of The Year 2025

Cigar Journal’s Best Buy Cigars Of The Year 2024

Cigar Journal’s Best Buy Cigars Of The Year 2023

Cigar Journal’s Best Buy Cigars of the year 2022

Cigar Journal’s Best Buy Cigars of the year 2021

Cigar Journal’s Best Buy Cigars of the Year 2020

CIGAR JOURNAL’S BEST BUY CIGARS OF 2019

Looking Back: Cigar Journal’s Best Buy Cigars of 2018

Trending Articles

Great Wall Cigar Hosts Product Launch Event in Hong Kong & Macau

Light em Up Lounge – October / November 2024

New Cohiba and Montecristo Short Humidors Year of the Snake

Puro Sabor 2025: Day 3

Puro Sabor Festival 2025: Day One

Alec Bradley Releases Uncut Pairing with Green River Distillery

Light em Up Lounge – January / February 2025

Maya Selva Cigars Premiere in Danlí, Honduras

GPC Brings on Jaime Flórez-Estrada As Global Chief Growth Officer

Light em Up Lounge – November / December 2024

Tabacalera USA Announces New Roles for Key Leadership

Twice The Celebration

Oliva and CSWC Create New Brochure of Rules

Vintage Cigar Lounge Opens in Dubai

Chip Goldeen Joins Cayman Cigar Co. as EVP of Sales

M. K. & Söhne takes over distribution rights for Rocky Patel

Puro Sabor Festival 2025: Day 2

Fourth of July Going Black