Each year, our tasting panel members smoke hundreds of cigars in order to give you the results of these blind tastings with the most objective impressions possible through our ratings. At the end of the year, we traditionally use the occasion to select those cigars that have remained in our memory.

Only the cigars that received a combined score of 90 points or more and those that were initially released less than two years ago are eligible for selection.

#7 | San Lotano Dominicano Toro

Collaborations are increasingly popular between brands and cigar personalities. The San Lotano Dominicano is one such collaboration between Abdel “A.J.” Fernández and José “Jochy” Blanco.
A.J. Fernández owns the brand, while Jochy Blanco produces the cigar at Tabacalera Palma. The Toro is presented in boxes of 20.

Tasting notes:
This Toro keeps the palate on its toes: wood, earth, coffee, the scent of bread and flowery notes are in the creamy smoke. The sweetness of licorice, molasses and cacao follow, as well as leather aromas … a magnificent, robust, and expressive cigar.

Owner: A.J. Fernández Cigars
Factory: Tabacalera Palma
Origin: Dom. Rep.
Wrapper: Brazil
Binder: Nicaragua
Filler: Nicaragua
Strength: 8 (out of 10)
Size: 152 x 19.8 | 6 x 50
Released: 2019

#6| Liga Privada No.9 Corona Viva

First presented at the 2018 IPCPR (now PCA), the Corona Gorda format, features a Connecticut River Valley Broadleaf wrapper, Brazilian Mata Fina binder, and filler from Honduras and Nicaragua.

Tasting notes:
In the creamy smoke of this cigar there is a chocolate sweetness, woody aromas, notes of fruit, the scent of bread and coffee, as well as roasted aromas. A very complex blend with a lot of spice, some pepperiness, and a fine sweetness.

Owner: Drew Estate LLC
Factory: La Gran Fabrica Drew Estate
Origin: Nicaragua
Wrapper: USA
Binder: Brazil
Filler: Nicaragua, Honduras
Strength: 6 (out of 10)
Size: 152 x 18.3 | 6 x 46
Released: 2018

#5 | Vegas del Purial Gran Reserva Super Toro

This new series comes from El Galan Cigars S.A., Estelí, Nicaragua. The blend was developed by Felix Mesa, lovingly called El Guajiro by his friends, and is an homage to his family. Vegas del Purial refers to the name of the farm in Cuba on which his paternal grandparents cultivated tobacco. The blend of the lines are characterized by the sensory aromas of coffee, earthy/woody tones, and notes of fruit. The dimensions of the Super Toro are ideal for a long intermezzo. Further available formats are a Robusto, Belicoso and a Lancero; each come in 20-count boxes, respectively.

Tasting notes:
Robust aromas of oak, roasted nuts and leather mingle with the sweetness of chocolate. A very creamy cigar, rich in content and gentle. Later, it develops a fine aroma of spices.

Owner: Aroma de Vuelta Abajo, Inc.
Factory: El Galan Cigars S.A.
Origin: Nicaragua
Wrapper: Ecuador
Binder: Nicaragua
Filler: Nicaragua
Strength: 6 (out of 10)
Size: 171 x 20.6 | 6 3/4 x 52
Released: 2018

#4 | Punch Short de Punch

The modernization of the classic Habanos brands continues to progress, thanks to the trendy formats: larger ring gauges, but shorter in length. Habanos S.A. launched the Short de Punch in 2019 as the first 50 ring gauge of the Punch brand, which was founded in the mid-19th century with the intention of being established on the British cigar market. This is also evident in the brand name, which is derived from the very popular Victorian England cartoon Mr. Punch.

Tasting notes:
A really expressive, harmonious cigar with refreshing, intense sweet-fruity notes, elegant cedar aromas and a subtle herbal spice. Later on, the sweetness is more reminiscent of caramel; a gentle tart, nutty tone is added.

Owner: Empresa Cubana del Tabaco (Cubatabaco)
Factory: La Corona
Origin: Cuba
Wrapper: Cuba
Binder: Cuba
Filler: Cuba
Strength: 5 (out of 10)
Size: 121 x 19.8 | 4 3/4 x 50
Released: 2019

#3 | Alec & Bradley Blind Faith Gordo

Alan Rubin named his cigar brand that he founded in the 1990s after his two sons, Alec and Bradley. Now the boys have grown up and work for the family business. Blind Faith is the first line they created on their own and was presented in 2018. Apparently they have learned their craft well, because Blind Faith is a successful debut. According to their own information, it is the strongest cigar to date in the Alec Bradley portfolio. Aside from the Gordo, there also Toro and a Robusto.

Tasting notes:
The distinctive woody aroma of this cigar is accompanied by leather, subtle sweetness, coffee and fruity notes. During the smoke, this creamy cigar becomes more expressive, and develops extremely harmoniously.

Owner: Alec Bradley Cigar Corporation
Factory: Fabrica de Tabacos Raíces Cubanas S. de R.L.
Origin: Honduras
Wrapper: Honduras
Binder: Nicaragua, Honduras
Filler: Nicaragua
Strength: 6 (out of 10)
Size: 152 x 23.8 | 6 x 60
Released: 2018

#2 | Davidoff Winston Churchill LE 2019 The Traveller Robusto

Since ist relaunch in 2014, the brand Davidoff Winston Churchill has received numerous awards and extremely good reviews. In addition to the two main lines, Original Collection and  The Late Hour, Oettinger Davidoff sometimes also launches Limited Editions. This year, it is thematically dedicated to Winston Churchill\’92s many journeys, hence the name The Traveller The motif is also reflected on the package design: stamps of London, Washington and Marrakesh appear inside the boxes, which are outfitted with Boveda packs. As well as the Robusto, there is also a Corona, which is only available in the duty free markets outside the United States.

Tasting notes:
A firework of tastes of chocolate, dried fruit, Amaretto and leather, with a pinch of peppery spice. A creamy, harmonious blend with surprising nuances and flavors.

Owner: Oettinger Davidoff AG
Factory: Cidav
Origin: Dom. Rep.
Wrapper: Dom. Rep.
Binder: Mexico
Filler: Dom. Rep., Nicaragua
Strength: 7 (out of 10)
Size: 127 x 19.8 | 5 x 50
Released: 2019 (80,000 cigars)

Cigars # 25–20: December 9
Cigars # 19–14: December 10
Cigars # 13–8: December 11
Cigars # 7–2: December 12

Cigar of the Year 2019: December 13



    Related posts



    Get the latest cigar news monthly.

    Enter your email and join the global Cigar Journal family.


    By pressing the ‘I AM OF LEGAL AGE’ button, I agree that I am of legal age for smoking and drinking in my country.

    Send this to a friend